268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 68 (669 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Jason Seeley

11/11/2026
5.00

Butler Auto Sales are very customer oriented. We have bought seven vehicles from them over the years. They really care about their customers. This time around Brandan Collins was an exceptional salesman for us. Very personable and caring. Thank you.

Kimberly Dougherty

11/10/2026
5.00

Excellent Customer Service Brandan was excellent and knowledgeable.

Emma Constable

11/10/2026
5.00

Great first experience here at butlers. I got to work with Phil, who I couldn’t recommend more. Very personable and made it a very smooth process.

L. Milley

11/10/2026
5.00

Tyler made our buying experience flawless. Thank you

David Howard

11/09/2026
5.00

Incredibly easy to work with walked in with an idea in mind and Brandan got right with me and made the process painless. Great place with a lot of good people working there.

keiyonna

11/07/2026
5.00

I had an absolutely great experience working with Phil! He was hilarious, made the entire process enjoyable, and actually made buying my truck fun instead of stressful. He got me a great deal and made sure I was happy with everything. If you’re looking for a salesman who knows his stuff, has a great personality, and will make you laugh along the way, I highly recommend him! Definitely ask for him if you’re looking to buy a car! 🚗

Madison Kohlhepp

11/07/2026
5.00

First time buying a car at butlers and it was a great experience. Philip was very helpful and would recommend visiting if you need a new car.

Lisa Buel

11/07/2026
5.00

Once again an amazing experience dealing with Brandon Collins! Thank you and we will see you again!

Rachelle Collins

11/07/2026
5.00

Phil at Butlers Auto was super helpful and made the process of buying my car so simple. Couldn’t thank him enough!

Autumn Loucks

11/07/2026
5.00

Phil was amazing help looking for a new car! Went above and beyond!!

Page: 1 of 68 (669 reviews)

Text Us