268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 56 (550 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Robert Ambrosino

07/28/2026
5.00

Great salesman and great service

J D

07/27/2026
5.00

Phil was extremely helpful and great to work with. Overall, it was a great experience and I would recommend Butler Autosales to everyone!

kim caffray

07/24/2026
5.00

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐If you go to Butler Auto Sales and don’t ask for Scott, question your decision-making skills.Funny, honest, knowledgeable, and suspiciously easy to work with.Pretty sure Butler Auto Sales found a cheat code to selling cars and just named it Scott.Ask for him. You're welcome.

Patrick Sweeney

07/23/2026
5.00

I just purchased my Ram 2500 Laramie from Brooke, and she was amazing to work with. She was very communicative, and made the process incredibly smooth. Very happy with our experience with her at Butler.

Katelynn Smith

07/23/2026
5.00

Sales Associate Brooke Hayes made the sale smooth! Highly recommended

karly sutton

07/22/2026
5.00

Caleb was very helpful and made everything so easy for buying my first car! highly recommend him!

Jodi Hulbert

07/22/2026
5.00

Excellent customer service by Brandan Collins! We came in on a whim to just see what they had available and left with a fabulous trade in price on our jeep and a new VW Jetta! My husband and I will definitely be doing business with Brandan again!

K. Hen

07/22/2026
5.00

Philip youngs was my salesman and he did an amazing job.Was friendly and professional and did an amazing job. Would definitely buy from them again.

James Reynolds

07/22/2026
5.00

Brooke made sure that the process of buying the car easy and simple will keep going brooke

Kaitlyn Buzie

07/22/2026
5.00

Butler is the way to go! Absolutely love my new car. With the help of one of the workers there Brooke and the owner Tyler, I found my car. I had a great experience buying my car from this dealership! They were all very friendly, professional, and never made me feel pressured. They took the time to answer all of my questions, explained everything clearly, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. The vehicle was exactly as described, and I felt like they genuinely cared about helping me find the right car. I highly recommend this dealership to anyone looking for honest service and a positive car-buying experience. Thank you for making everything so easy! Got my 2023 Chevrolet equinox RS. Thank you so much!!!

Page: 1 of 56 (550 reviews)

Text Us