Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.
Sort By:
Per Page:
Dirty Bird Tj
08/04/2026
5.00
Had an easy going car buying experience with Butler's auto. Caleb Smith on top of his game!! Would highly recommend him as your salesperson.
Noel Sue
08/04/2026
5.00
We had an amazing privilege of working with Caleb Smith buying our new 2019 Jeep Compass at Butler's Sidney N.Y.. He was very polite and answered every question to the best of his knowledge and was on top of his game. Thank you for a wonderful but scary 1st time experience but making is feel comfortable ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
lasca mazzone
08/04/2026
5.00
Working with Phil Young’s was a pleasure he explained everything very clearly!!
anastasia baldwin
08/03/2026
5.00
We couldn’t have asked for a better car buying experience! Phil was absolutely amazing, we appreciate you staying late and putting up with our little ones through this process. Will most definitely be back
Michael Shearer
08/01/2026
5.00
Brandon was really good about finding me a car that fit my needs!
Bridget Gibbon
07/31/2026
5.00
Was treated with respect, and was very nice to work with . Would recommend his service. Brandon collins
Sam Marie
07/31/2026
5.00
I’ve gotten 2 cars from them so far. Everyone there is amazing. Definitely recommend.
Kohën Nelson
07/31/2026
5.00
Brandon was super helpful on selling me my car! Amazing Subaru legacy, he was always available to answer any questions I had. Highly recommend!
joe mueller
07/31/2026
5.00
Painless car buying, Phil knows his cars and found me what I wanted!
Tia Pangburn
07/30/2026
5.00
Caleb Smith was a great sales man! He did not pressure and worked with me! The whole experience with Butler Auto Sales was five stars!
