268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 43 (420 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Kelly M

05/12/2026
5.00

Brandon collins at butler auto sales was great. Very quick polite and professional. He was not afraid to answer my questions and made the entire experience great. Entire staff was very professional and friendly.

Shell Shelt

05/11/2026
5.00

Tammy Hall

05/09/2026
5.00

My husband’s transmission died in his truck. He needed a new truck asap. We tried a few other dealerships but there was some red flags.A friend told me about Butler Auto. So we decided to give them a try. We are so glad we did. It was so worth the hour drive. Brooke, the sales person, was excellent. We were very happy there. We will definitely be recommending her and Butler Auto to others.The sale and transition went smoothly. Thank you again Brooke.

Jason Rennells

05/09/2026
5.00

We have dealt with several dealerships in the past. Butler Auto Sales was great. Our Sales person, Brooke, was by far the best Sales person we've ever had. She was so sweet. She was not pushy. Brooke goes above and beyong to make sure you get the vehicle you want and qualify for.Butler Auto Sales was totally worth the hour drive.

Kaden Cicio

05/09/2026
5.00

Phil helped me buy my first truck

Kiarra Roe

05/09/2026
5.00

Debra Bush

05/08/2026
5.00

Always enjoy working with Brandan as he is pressure and hassle free. Thank you again butler auto sales

Kelly Nichols

05/08/2026
5.00

Scott Tacinelli sold us a new car. He was so professional kind and courteous. He even came and picked me up so I didn’t have to walk. What a fine experience he gave us . Thank you for making this process painless

kylee pitcher

05/07/2026
5.00

Brandon helped me and my grandmother and he was awesome. He made everything super easy for us to understand and helped us so much!

Cynthia Wright

05/07/2026
5.00

“Working with Brandan was such a great experience from start to finish. They were patient, knowledgeable, and never made me feel pressured during the process. They took the time to answer all my questions and helped me find the perfect vehicle for my needs and budget. The whole experience was smooth, stress-free, and actually enjoyable. I highly recommend asking for Brandan if you’re looking for someone honest, professional, and genuinely helpful!”

Page: 1 of 43 (420 reviews)

Text Us