268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 67 (656 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Peter

10/30/2026
5.00

Thank you to Brandon for all his help in the process of buying my brand new truck to me

Jordan Mullen

10/28/2026
5.00

Very friendly and helpful staff. Would recommend anyone to buy from them

Julie Uciechowski

10/28/2026
5.00

Very helpful. Happy with them. Thank you Brandan Collin’s

Tori Henderson

10/26/2026
5.00

I completely recommend Butlers Auto!! Caleb was great, very helpful!!

Scarlet Henderson

10/26/2026
5.00

Caleb Smith was absolutely wonderful. I would recommend Butler's to anyone.

Dustin Wood

10/23/2026
5.00

Brandan was excellent. I enjoyed the interaction and was pleased that he was straightforward and respectful through the process.

Zach Harrington

10/21/2026
5.00

Brandon was awesome! He helped me so much. He talked and walked me through everything and explained everything to me. Would recommend butlers auto and have Brandon help you 100 percent.

Tyler Sherman

10/21/2026
5.00

Awesome experience Phil helped me out alot would recommend

april feyh

10/20/2026
5.00

We just bought our 3rd vehicle from Butler and are once again very impressed with the truly exceptional customer service we received. Caleb professionally answered our vehicle questions, even on his day off, Todd moved very quickly to get us approved, and Phillip kindly got us through all the paperwork so we could take our vehicle home. They all worked as a team, to put us in a quality vehicle at a reasonable price.

Lisa Reese

10/20/2026
5.00

Working with Branden Collin’s was a pleasure. He helped me find the right car for the price I had in mind. This is my second vehicle from them and I could not be happier.

Page: 1 of 67 (656 reviews)

Text Us