268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 36 (348 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Kay-Lyne Brown

04/07/2026
5.00

Bought a vehicle from Butler’s Auto Sales and worked with Brooke. I’ll be honest, I’m not big on car shopping, but this was actually a pretty easy, low-stress experience. Brooke was straightforward, easy to deal with, and didn’t make it feel like a typical pushy sales situation.Nothing over-the-top or salesy, just got in, got it done, and drove off happy. Which, let’s be real, is exactly what you want.Would recommend if you’re looking for a simple, no-hassle car buying experience.

Keegan Sherwood

04/05/2026
5.00

Phil was great. Really made us feel like we could trust him and he found a solid car for my mother to drive. I'm taking all my car shopping to this guy from now on. Thanks again Phil!!

Deb Rose

04/03/2026
5.00

Brooke was amazing and made the entire experience easy and comfortable. Truly earned a customer for life

Rebecca Pom

04/02/2026
5.00

I walked in to butler's auto sales a few weeks ago trying to trade my car in i got the pleasure to work with Phil he was amazing 👏 and truly caring ready to help he got me in and out in a day span by five I was impressed thank 😊 you butler auto sales pleased and excited for my new adventures in my vw Taos!! Well appreciated 👏 Phil was amazing 👏

Gary Eggleston

04/02/2026
5.00

Dealt with Phil at Butler Auto on buying a car he does everything he can to make the transaction a pleasure. Nothing but help you out !

Casey Griswold

04/02/2026
5.00

I love the energy at butlers amazing service! And amazing people ! Philip young’s is by far my favorite person to deal with !

Sheli Frattarelli

04/02/2026
5.00

Brandon is the best! I have worked with him many times over the last 10 years and have been nothing but happy with my service every time. Purchasing a car from butlers is easy and fun. Now I get to drive home in my dream car.

Spencer Gransbury

04/02/2026
5.00

Great and friendly service

Riley

03/31/2026
5.00

Philip was absolutely amazing listened to every concern and made sure I felt comfortable. This was my first ever car purchase on my own. His communication from the start was amazing! Any questions I asked he knew the answer. I was nervous going in but came out feeling absolutely confident in my decision. I love the car and couldn’t be happier! Definitely recommend!

Lexie Marie

03/31/2026
5.00

Writing this on behalf of my grandmother ! She just recently bought a Subaru outback and would like to thank Phil for his patience and help with the whole process. As she has found the car she’s been looking for and couldn’t be happier !

Page: 1 of 36 (348 reviews)

Text Us