268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 24 (226 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Matt Ford

10/16/2025
5.00

Blew a transmission in my truck, butler's handled everything with the warranty and had me fixed up and going in no time! Never had a warranty claim and fix job go so smooth appreciate it!

Cynthia Kinsey

10/13/2025
5.00

I have. Never had a problem of any kind.Indeed in dealing with butler auto. Everyone is kind, courteous and helpful.\n I'm always greeted with a smile and whatever concerns I have are addressed as quickly as possible.

Ruth Panek

10/12/2025
5.00

The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. They answered all my question and I would recommend them, absolutely.....Phil and Tyler are the best salespeople I have ever met..I was just looking and ended up with Subaru Sport. Love the car and great deal....

Cheryl Nages

10/03/2025
5.00

Jacquelyn Sherman

10/01/2025
5.00

Brooke was amazing! I purchased a 2023 Jeep Grand Cherokee and it was the best experience!

Rich Gervasi

09/22/2025
5.00

Great place to buy a car. From the owner Tyler ,very flexible ,professional, to Scott my salesman ,terrific young fellow ,respectful ,easy going, knowledgeable, to Kevin ,one of the managers ,so patient with his time ,to do everything making the customer happy ,to Charlotte ,the receptionist, very pleasant young lady. I'm a very happy customer. Thank u to all...Rich

Aron Howe

09/14/2025
5.00

We bought our GMC terrain about a yr ago was a great vehicle until the accident. They did a great job communicating and never any issues with the vehicle

Pamela Peck

09/12/2025
5.00

My experience with Butler's was a absolute pleasure!! EVERYONE there is not only friendly, but helpful and knowledgeable. If and when I purchase another vehicle it will definitely be with them. I highly recommend them.

Jerry Shriver

09/10/2025
4.00

I would rate our experience between Average and Above Average. There were areas that I think you could have done better - such as in communication about the status of receiving the car. On at least two occasions, times of pick-up were given and not kept. That would have been acceptable if you had called to tell us. Also repairs have taken at least three weeks before completion. This is not really acceptable. Having said this, we like Butler's and will use them for future purchases.

Richard Rutenber

08/21/2025
5.00

Great experience while shopping for new car. Always feel comfortable with the staff.

Page: 1 of 24 (226 reviews)

Text Us