268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 35 (338 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Riley

03/31/2026
5.00

Philip was absolutely amazing listened to every concern and made sure I felt comfortable. This was my first ever car purchase on my own. His communication from the start was amazing! Any questions I asked he knew the answer. I was nervous going in but came out feeling absolutely confident in my decision. I love the car and couldn’t be happier! Definitely recommend!

Carol Saggese

03/30/2026
5.00

Phil Young helped me find just the car I was looking for. Butler’s staff were helpful and pleasant.

Michael Towndrow

03/30/2026
5.00

Absolutely phenomenal experience, Phil helped me out and got me a great deal on my new Kia Forte GT, went from a 2011 challenger to a 2024 Kia Forte cause he put the time and Effort into getting me the best deal possible

Ziggy. BIGYANKEE

03/30/2026
5.00

My car sales woman Mrs. Hayes was extremely nice, she went over everything and Made sure that I understood everything. It was good time

CLP West

03/30/2026
4.00

Jenna

03/30/2026
5.00

Phil was extremely helpful and made the whole experience easy and enjoyable! He made sure that I was completely satisfied with my decision even months after purchasing. Highly recommend!

Erika Atchinson

03/30/2026
5.00

We purchased our second vehicle from Butler Auto Sales this past weekend and experienced the same ease and comfort with the buying process as we had the first time. Phil was an exceptional salesman, but without the pressure and "salesy" attitude. He answered any and all questions, explained the much more modern features, and even connected my phone to the car before I left the lot. All interactions with staff were pleasant. I would highly recommend Butler Auto Sales, and be sure to ask for Phil!

Mackenzie Emerson

03/30/2026
5.00

Phil was great to work with, very helpful and a very quick turnaround time!

Jason James

03/28/2026
5.00

I got my ford escape and am so happy with not just my purchase but how amazing the sales person Brooke Hayes helped and went the extra mile to get me in a safe vehicle thank you for everything you did and I am so excited for more purchases with butlers auto sale ! -Daryl James

Kayla Quigley

03/27/2026
5.00

Phil Youngs is helpful and is able to make the car buying experience easy and fun!

Page: 1 of 35 (338 reviews)

Text Us