268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 33 (317 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Monique hicks-watson

03/15/2026
5.00

savanna adams

03/14/2026
5.00

Brooke was very helpful and made the process of getting my new car very pleasant! She’s amazing at what she does!

Travis Foster

03/13/2026
5.00

Jill

03/12/2026
5.00

10/10 Brandan Collins works with you so good and goes into perfect details about what everything is. I highly recommend coming here for a car if you can’t afford a big payment on cars.

Crystal Foulds

03/12/2026
5.00

Very friendly enjoyed working with them

Hannah Hinkley

03/11/2026
5.00

Thank you Brooke Hayes for an amazing experience buying my new car! Very patient, very thorough, super friendly and knowledgeable! Highly recommend Butlers Auto Sales for your next car!!

Anthony Ciralli

03/11/2026
5.00

2 cars in one year. Very nice. People take care of u if there is a problem Brandan Collins was the one how help me. He is the best

Courtney Marino

03/10/2026
5.00

If you’re lucky enough to work with Phil while buying a vehicle, consider yourself in excellent hands. Our family just purchased a Jeep Wagoneer last week, and the experience from start to finish was honestly one of the best car-buying experiences we’ve ever had—largely thanks to Phil.From the very beginning, Phil stood out because he truly listened. He took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for, what our expectations were, and what mattered most to our family. Instead of trying to steer us toward vehicles we weren’t interested in (which so many salespeople tend to do), he respected our preferences and focused only on the options that made sense for us. That alone made the process feel comfortable and stress-free.Phil was incredibly thorough and knowledgeable throughout the entire process. Every question we had—big or small—was answered clearly and honestly. You could tell he wasn’t just trying to make a sale; he genuinely wanted us to feel confident and happy with our decision. He walked us through everything step-by-step, making sure we understood all the features of the Wagoneer, the numbers involved, and what to expect next.Communication was another area where Phil absolutely excelled. He kept us updated at every stage of the process, which made everything feel smooth and transparent. Whether it was checking in with updates, letting us know where things stood, or making sure we had everything we needed, he was consistently attentive and responsive.When it came time to discuss our trade-in, Phil was fair and straightforward. There were no games, no pressure, and no uncomfortable back-and-forth. He worked with us to make sure we received a fair offer, and we really appreciated how honest and respectful that part of the process was.What really impressed us, though, is that Phil’s service didn’t stop once the sale was complete. He has continued to stay in touch afterward just to make sure we’re happy with the Wagoneer and that everything is going well. That level of follow-up says a lot about the kind of professional—and person—he is.Buying a car can sometimes feel overwhelming, but Phil made the experience enjoyable, easy, and even fun. He’s professional, personable, patient, and genuinely kind. Our family couldn’t be happier with our new Wagoneer, and we’re incredibly grateful to Phil for making the whole experience such a positive one.If you’re looking for someone who will be honest, helpful, thorough, and truly invested in making sure you drive away happy, Phil is your guy. We would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking for their next vehicle. Thanks again, Phil—you made this a fantastic experience for our family!

Flight 737-200

03/07/2026
5.00

Awesome experience. Brandon was most helpful when buying my new truck. Always friendly. Service is always a 5 star! Thank you!

Rebeca Stoesser

03/06/2026
5.00

I love my new car! Brooke was so nice and Helpful!!

Page: 1 of 33 (317 reviews)

Text Us