268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 45 (439 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Theodore Dicks

05/26/2026
5.00

Butler has treated me pretty Farley. I had a couple of problems with the car and they fixed it with no expense to me. From the time I looked at the car to buying and driving it, they were with me all the way. They are friendly people that will bend over backwards to help you. I'd go back to buy another car or truck with no problem.

Paula Barrows

05/26/2026
5.00

Marissa Ballin

05/22/2026
5.00

Thank Brandon for all you have done you had great service and I loved working with you thanks Butlers for having such great employees

Sierra Musk

05/22/2026
5.00

Scott has amazing and so freaking healpful, I put my mind to something and he helped me get it done!

Lisa McCarthy

05/22/2026
4.00

We have been buying vehicles from Butler Auto for years. Always a good experience and Brandan Collins is very helpful and fun to deal with!

Bonnie Walters

05/21/2026
5.00

I totally trusted my sales person in helping with the selection of a new 2 me vehicle. He understood what I needed as far as payment and type if vehicle for my needs. Gave me several to choose from then offered his opinion as best for me. His honesty is above and beyond just selling a vehicle to sell a vehicle. I will definitely be recommending to friends in the future!

Amber King

05/21/2026
5.00

Brandan Collins was super helpful & made buying a new car quick & easy! Super friendly guy, will be returning when needed!

Carter S

05/20/2026
5.00

My second purchase with Butler Auto. Quick, easy, no pressure sale!!! Thank you Tyler Butler and Philip Youngs

Maegan Hitt

05/20/2026
5.00

Philip Youngs helped me get a new vehicle when my current vehicle needed multiple repairs was able to get much new vehicle for very reasonable price and warranty

Richard Rogers

05/18/2026
5.00

Overall the Car buying experience was great! Brooke reached out shortly after I inquired about a vehicle and was extremely helpful through the entire process. At no point was I handed off to another sales associate or felt forced into extra’s. This was the second car we have purchased from Butler and once we are in the market for another vehicle it will be the first place we look.

Page: 1 of 45 (439 reviews)

Text Us