268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 42 (408 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Nate Beardsley

05/05/2026
5.00

Brandon was the easiest to work with! From walking the lot to closing on the car. Easy quick and incredibly friendly. 10/10 would recommend!

Stephanie Buchannon

05/05/2026
5.00

Brandan helped me with my jeep and he had the greatest attitude and was very polite! He was very friendly and answered any questions I had. I have bought 2 vehicles from here and would absolutely come back again!!

cassandra beardsley

05/04/2026
5.00

Good guy to deal with easy going. Will put you in a vehicle you want.

A Scott

05/04/2026
5.00

Scott TacinelliWas amazing working with me

Ethan Brown

05/02/2026
5.00

Brooke was amazing! Explained everything very clearly, was patient when making a decision, responsive and you can tell she cares for her customers!Everyone at the office is caring and kind the entire time, always asking if there’s something you need!Great establishment and plan to continue business for years to come!

Kody Hill

05/01/2026
5.00

Thank you Brooke and the Butler Auto team for getting me in my Jeep Wrangler. It was an easy going experience and I'm beyond happy with everything.

JAMES gillespie

05/01/2026
5.00

This was a great buying experience, both Tyler and Brooke were great to deal with, made sure everything was perfect, so easy to work with. Cant thank them enough. Butler stands behind their customers and makes sure they are satisfied when they leave with the new vehicle. They have a good business going there, will deal with them again when the time comes. Worth the drive!

pete ouimet

05/01/2026
5.00

Scott made the whole process fast, easy and stress free. I would recommend Scott and Butler Auto to anyone looking to purchase a new vehicle

Danielle Webster

04/30/2026
5.00

Brooke was amazing! She made the process quick simple and very easy to understand

Brian Strain

04/30/2026
5.00

Can’t say enough good things about Butler auto. The process was quick and painless. Brooke was a tremendous help with getting me in the car that I wanted. Highly recommended if you are looking for a new vehicle.

Page: 1 of 42 (408 reviews)

Text Us