268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522
168 Delaware Ave Sidney, NY 13838

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 21 (204 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Tarajeeps “Tarajeeps”

03/22/2025
5.00

This is an amazing business! Our salesman was Noah and he was very kind and patient with us, he did not make us feel stupid and didn't pressure us. He did everything he could to make it happen and answered every stupid question I had without judgement. Anything that I worried about Noah already had it figured out. We were truly blown away by his honesty, compassion and his professional abilities. If you're in the market for a vehicle, I highly recommend Butler Auto Sales, and be sure to ask for Noah! You won’t be disappointed. Thanks Noah! Tara and Thomas

Shain Bakker

03/13/2025
5.00

Summer Merithew

03/02/2025
5.00

Jeff was great to work with. My husband and I couldn’t be happier with how our new car purchase went. 10/10

Bill

02/15/2025
5.00

ryan Luttinger

02/12/2025
5.00

Mihai Musca

02/07/2025
5.00

100% recommend Scott to work with here! He is wonderful! Very helpful and friendly! Highly recommend! Ask for Scott when you walk in!

Christina Miller

01/27/2025
5.00

I have two boys that just both purchased there cars. It was easiest and best experience we have had. I personally when ready will be going there to buy myself a new car. Thanks butler auto!!!!!

Terri Slater

01/11/2025
5.00

Amazing product line up and quality team. Jeff and Tyler were helpful and supportive. Thank you again.

Stoner Steve

12/14/2024
5.00

This was definitely the easiest car purchase I've ever made thanks to Jeff Newman the best salesperson that I've ever dealt with . Thanks to the Butler family for my new beautiful Jeep !! I definitely recommend that if you need a vehicle, to make Butler auto sales your first stop , I'll bet it will be your last 😉

Toby Alter

11/06/2024
5.00

I was referred by a co- worker to Butler's auto sales after hitting a deer with are vehicle. Amber Lawson was are sales representative and we couldn't ask for a better person to help us with selecting our new car. We met her on Friday, we picked out a car that same day and got financed. By Monday afternoon we had are new car at home. I couldn't have asked for a smoother transaction. Thanks again to the sales team.

Page: 1 of 21 (204 reviews)

Text Us